This is a brief list of some of my favorite places to eat in the Sarasota area (Be sure to look for my top 5 recommended beaches to visit, coming soon). The following restaurants range greatly in style, type of food and cost. I will do my best to provide a description of each restaurant, free of any bias and from a local, not a tourist expecting an oftentimes unrealistic experience because they're on vacation. Don't get me wrong, I myself often use sites such as tripadvisor.com to read reviews but I have realized as of late that many of the reviews are written from the business's themselves in an attempt to better their ranking. I have also realized that those who are on vacation vs. those who call the local area home, usually have very different views on local establishments. You can also follow me on Twitter @justinedmonds to stay informed on places to eat, things to see and which beaches to visit.
Prices are defined as :
(Prices are per plate and do not include drinks)
Top 5 Beachy places to dine while in the Sarasota, FL area:
Sharky's on the Pier
1600 Harbor Dr S
Venice, FL 34285
Sharky's offers patrons the option of both indoor dining (with a bit pricier menu) and outdoor dining located at the base of a very large fishing pier. Personally, I have never eaten inside, the outdoor dining has great accommodations including: Live Entertainment weekly (Entertainment calendar is always listed on the website), Tiki Bar, Ceiling fans to provide a little more of a breeze for those extra hot days and ceiling heaters when the nights get a bit chilly on the water in winter. The tiki bar offers a wide selection of frozen drinks and drafts. Sharky's is very family oriented, after dinner you are able to take a stroll down to the end of the pier (free but no alcohol) and maybe get a glimpse of some local fishers pulling in a shark.
Pop's Sunset Grill is a great place to hang with locals due to its slightly secluded location. Pop's offers both indoor and outdoor seating, waterfront and barside. Pop's is unique because of the ability to pull up in your boat and park dockside, accessible via the Intracoastal Waterway. Pop's menu is the same whether you choose to dine inside or out and is full of several basket type selections. There is always a good selection of fresh catches to choose from. Though its not always on the menu, I would recommend requesting the Grouper fingers or the Bahama Mama Burger, both choices are delicious. Try Pop's for dinner on a Saturday night and then walk across the bridge over to Casey Key to enjoy a famous local gather at the beach known as "The Drum Party".
5250 Ocean Blvd
Sarasota, FL 34242-3309
The Daiquiri Deck is located in the heart of the Village of Siesta Key. Siesta Key is known to have the whitest sand and some of the best nightlife in the area. I've eaten at the Daiquiri Deck several times and have always been completely satisfied with the selection, service, ambiance and most importantly for this location, a huge selection of various different Daiquiris. After dinner and drinks, it's just a short stroll to ice cream shops, souvenir's, and plenty more bars and dance clubs. Walking the opposite way about a mile will lead to the world famous Siesta Key Beach.
The BeachHouse Restaurant
200 Gulf Drive
Bradenton Beach, FL 34217
The BeachHouse Restaurant is located slightly
north of Sarasota but is well worth the drive to enjoy the experience that is offered by this restaurant. GPS may instruct you to follow 41 to Cortez road but there is a much more scenic route available by following Gulf of Mexico drive North from St. Armands Circle. Along the way you will see: Beautiful homes, Golf Courses, Banyan Trees and views of the Gulf that are unbeatable. The BeachHouse is located at the south end of Anna Maria Island just outside the quiet fishing village of Cortez. The menu offers several different options from beachy basket food to Filet and Lobster. As for location I would rate the views and ambiance #2 only to Sharky's and only because of the pier walk one can enjoy at Sharky's.
Tommy Bahamas Tropical Cafe
300 John Ringling Blvd
Sarasota, FL 34236
Tommy Bahama's is exactly what you would expect, Superb Quality, Service and Ambiance. This Tropical Cafe is located on a busy corner on Sarasota's famous St. Armands Circle. Though this restaurant is not located directly on the beach or waterway like the other 4 listed, it's location is actually my favorite of all because of its proximity to everything one would want to see in Florida. A short walk can lead you to dozens of bars, ice cream shops, souvenir shops, the beach and art galleries. The menu includes several dishes that are unlike anything I have ever had before. The restaurant is located above the Tommy Bahama store, there is a patio on the 2nd floor that is great for an after dinner drink. I would highly recommend reservations.
Here are a couple other sites offering information on what to do and see in the Sarasota Area: